About HLBS, HLOF i totally agree. HLBS is better than HLOF.
HLOF, to me, looks less canonical because of Race X.
Race X in HLOF seems to me to turn Half-Life lore into some sort of fanfic.
Race X to me is like pineapple in a pizza if I were Italian.
But I disagree with EP1 and EP2, for me EP2 is better than EP1 because of the unique content (EP1 happens more in City17, which we have already seen in HL2. EP2 takes place in new locations outside the city).
I mostly agree with this. Though I would place Half-Life: Opposing Force into the "Good" tier, and put Half-Life: Blue-Shift into the "Not good enough" tier.
Participants so far :
Mr.Shokoladka (the one who posted the list)
NeonOn (the guy who beat Half-Life with ONLY the glock and crowbar)
Redeye (Sven co-op master)
Mimouv (Algeria's (dis)connections, Always closer (everyone is suffering) )
Me :D
Missing the best campaign in the series: Decay
bro was bold posting that
About HLBS, HLOF i totally agree. HLBS is better than HLOF. HLOF, to me, looks less canonical because of Race X. Race X in HLOF seems to me to turn Half-Life lore into some sort of fanfic. Race X to me is like pineapple in a pizza if I were Italian. But I disagree with EP1 and EP2, for me EP2 is better than EP1 because of the unique content (EP1 happens more in City17, which we have already seen in HL2. EP2 takes place in new locations outside the city).
opposing force fans when you like blue shift more
I mostly agree with this. Though I would place Half-Life: Opposing Force into the "Good" tier, and put Half-Life: Blue-Shift into the "Not good enough" tier.
Participants so far : Mr.Shokoladka (the one who posted the list) NeonOn (the guy who beat Half-Life with ONLY the glock and crowbar) Redeye (Sven co-op master) Mimouv (Algeria's (dis)connections, Always closer (everyone is suffering) ) Me :D