Half life or Black Mesa?
Great comparison. I really loved the fan made HL1 Black Mesa trailer.
As for which - I genuinely love both for different reasons.
Half-Life will always be the best to me because it's the original and what I grew up with.
Black Mesa has done an amazing job and modernizing the game whilst maintaining the original feel of the game whilst introducing lots of new things that make it a whole new game too.
Black Mesaaa is ma favorit
if you like black mesa more you have small pp if it's not at least the 2012 version
no I am acidic